North American Caterpillars

Sphinx Moth Caterpillar vs Tomato Hornworm

A tomato hornworm is a sphinx moth caterpillar. Learn how to tell it from the tobacco hornworm by its stripes and horn color, and whether it is safe to handle.

On this page
  1. Sphinx moth caterpillars and hornworms
  2. Tomato hornworm vs tobacco hornworm
  3. Adults: five-spotted hawkmoth vs Carolina sphinx
  4. Life cycle and generations
  5. Other sphinx caterpillars you may find
  6. What does a green hornworm turn into?
  7. Hummingbird moth vs sphinx moth
  8. Are sphinx moth caterpillars harmful?
  9. Is it safe to touch a tomato hornworm?
  10. What to do about them
  11. Common misconceptions

A tomato hornworm is one kind of sphinx moth caterpillar. “Sphinx moth” is the name for the whole family, Sphingidae, and “hornworm” is the common name for the caterpillars that have a horn at the rear. The tomato hornworm (Manduca quinquemaculata) becomes the five-spotted hawkmoth. Its close relative, the tobacco hornworm (Manduca sexta), becomes the Carolina sphinx. Both can strip tomato plants, and both are harmless to handle.

Sphinx moth caterpillars and hornworms

Hornworms are sphinx moth caterpillars. The family includes many species, including the UK’s hawk-moth caterpillars, and most of them feed on wild plants and trees rather than garden crops. Only a few are common tomato pests, so not every sphinx caterpillar you find is a problem for your garden.

Tomato hornworm vs tobacco hornworm

Use markings, not body color, to tell them apart. Both are usually green, and both can reach about 3 to 4 inches (7.5 to 10 cm).

Feature Tomato hornworm Tobacco hornworm
Scientific name Manduca quinquemaculata Manduca sexta
Side markings Eight white V-shaped chevrons per side Seven diagonal white stripes, edged in black
Horn Dark blue or black Red or reddish
Adult moth Five-spotted hawkmoth Carolina sphinx

Despite its name, the tobacco hornworm is often the species found on tomatoes, and it is more common in the South. Both feed on plants in the nightshade family (Solanaceae), including tomato, pepper, eggplant, potato and tobacco.

Adults: five-spotted hawkmoth vs Carolina sphinx

Both adults are large, brown moths. To tell them apart, count the yellow spots on the abdomen. The five-spotted hawkmoth has five pairs, and the Carolina sphinx has six.

Life cycle and generations

The caterpillar pupates in the soil, a few inches down. The pupa is brown, with a sheath for the proboscis that looks like a jug handle. In the north there are one or two generations a year. In the Deep South there can be three or four.

Other sphinx caterpillars you may find

  • White-lined sphinx. Feeds on many plants.
  • Tersa sphinx. Feeds on pentas and buttonweed. See are tersa sphinx moth caterpillars poisonous?
  • Pandorus and Abbott’s sphinx. Feed on grape and Virginia creeper. Some lose the horn as they grow, and it is replaced by an eyespot or a button.
  • Hummingbird clearwing. Feeds on viburnum and honeysuckle.

What does a green hornworm turn into?

On tomatoes and peppers, a green hornworm is usually a tomato or tobacco hornworm. Those become a five-spotted hawkmoth or a Carolina sphinx. Other green sphinx caterpillars, such as the white-lined sphinx, become different moths. Identify the species by its markings and horn first, and then match it to the adult.

Hummingbird moth vs sphinx moth

Hummingbird moths are sphinx moths. “Sphinx moth” is the name for the family, and “hummingbird moth” is a common name for the day-flying species in the genus Hemaris, often called hummingbird clearwings. So the choice is not between two different groups. Europe’s hummingbird hawk-moth is another day-flying sphinx moth, in a different genus; see hawk moths of the UK. The main differences are these:

  • Activity time. Hummingbird clearwings fly by day. Many other sphinx moths fly at dusk or at night.
  • Wings. Clearwings have mostly clear wings. Many sphinx moths have patterned brown or gray wings.
  • Caterpillars. The hummingbird clearwing caterpillar feeds on viburnum and honeysuckle, not tomato.

Are sphinx moth caterpillars harmful?

To plants, some are. Tomato and tobacco hornworms can strip leaves and chew fruit, and they can defoliate a small plant quickly. Most other sphinx caterpillars feed on wild plants and trees, and many do little harm. To people, they are not dangerous. The horn does not sting or inject venom. For caterpillars that do sting, see stinging and poisonous caterpillars.

Is it safe to touch a tomato hornworm?

Yes. Hornworms are harmless to handle. They may thrash or click their mandibles, which can be startling. Wash your hands afterward as a general precaution.

What to do about them

  • Handpick. Drop the caterpillars into soapy water, or give them to birds or chickens.
  • Use Bt on small larvae. Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki works best on small caterpillars. Spray the leaves the caterpillars eat.
  • Leave wasp-parasitized hornworms alone. A hornworm with white, rice-like cocoons on its back is carrying Cotesia congregata, a parasitic braconid wasp. Leave the caterpillar in place so the wasps can emerge and go on to attack other hornworms.

Common misconceptions

  • The horn does not sting or inject venom.
  • Not every sphinx caterpillar is a garden pest.
  • Stripe count and horn color, not body color, separate the tomato hornworm from the tobacco hornworm.
  • The tobacco hornworm is often the species on tomatoes, despite its name.

The complete guide to north american caterpillars

Caterpillar Identification: A Guide for North America
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →