North American Caterpillars

Black Swallowtail Caterpillar: How to Identify It in the Garden

Identify black swallowtail caterpillars by their black bands with yellow dots and lack of filaments, and learn which herbs they eat and how to protect them.

On this page
  1. Eggs and early stages: bird droppings
  2. Late stage: green with black bands
  3. Host plants
  4. The osmeterium
  5. Chrysalis and overwintering
  6. Look-alikes
  7. Garden tips
  8. Common misconceptions
  9. Safety

The black swallowtail caterpillar feeds on carrot-family herbs such as parsley, dill and fennel. Late-stage caterpillars are smooth and green, with black bands dotted with yellow-orange, and they have no filaments. The youngest ones look like bird droppings.

Eggs and early stages: bird droppings

The eggs are round, pale yellow and about 1 mm across. The female lays them singly on host leaves and flowers. The young caterpillar is black and spiny, with a white “saddle” across its middle, so it looks like a bird dropping. This disguise helps it avoid predators. Other swallowtails, including the tiger, spicebush and anise, have young stages that look similar.

Late stage: green with black bands

Late-stage caterpillars are smooth, green or whitish-green. Each segment has a black band dotted with yellow-orange. There are no hairs, spines or filaments. A full-grown caterpillar is about 2 inches (5 cm) long.

The caterpillar goes through five instars. The larval stage takes about two to four weeks, depending on the temperature.

Host plants

Black swallowtail caterpillars eat plants in the carrot family (Apiaceae), including:

  • parsley
  • dill
  • fennel
  • carrot
  • Queen Anne’s lace
  • golden alexanders

They also eat rue. Signs of feeding are chewed leaves and stems on these herbs.

The osmeterium

When it is disturbed, the caterpillar pushes out an orange, forked, Y-shaped organ behind its head called the osmeterium. It releases a sour odour. The osmeterium is not a stinger, and it is harmless to people. It is a defence against predators.

Chrysalis and overwintering

The chrysalis is green or brown and is held upright by a silk girdle around its middle. In the north, the species has two or three generations a year, and in the South it has more. Many chrysalises overwinter.

Look-alikes

  • Anise swallowtail (Papilio zelicaon). In the West, its larva is very similar and feeds on the same plants.
  • Monarch. Monarchs have filaments and eat only milkweed. Black swallowtails have no filaments. See monarch caterpillar identification.
  • Milkweed tussock moth. It is hairy, with tufts in black, orange and white, and it feeds in groups.

For the wider method, see the caterpillar identification guide.

Garden tips

  • Plant extra parsley or dill. Caterpillars rarely kill herbs, and planting extra usually covers both the caterpillars and your harvest.
  • If you want butterflies, avoid spraying Bt or insecticides on host herbs.
  • Wild parsnip is also in the carrot family, and its sap can cause phototoxic burns. Wear gloves around it.

Common misconceptions

  • Black swallowtail caterpillars are not monarchs. Monarchs have filaments and live only on milkweed.
  • The osmeterium is not a stinger and is harmless.
  • Young bird-dropping larvae are not a different species.
  • Black swallowtail caterpillars rarely kill herbs.

Safety

The caterpillars are harmless to handle. Wash your hands after touching any caterpillar or plant, and be careful around wild parsnip.

The complete guide to north american caterpillars

Caterpillar Identification: A Guide for North America
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →