Eastern tent and forest tent caterpillars look alike, but the back is the main clue. Eastern tent caterpillars have a solid white stripe down the back and build a large silk tent in branch crotches. Forest tent caterpillars have a row of white, keyhole-shaped spots down the back and build no tent. They rest on silk mats on trunks and branches instead.
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Eastern tent caterpillar | Forest tent caterpillar |
|---|---|---|
| Scientific name | Malacosoma americanum | Malacosoma disstria |
| Back marking | Solid white stripe | Row of white keyhole or footprint-shaped spots |
| Shelter | Large silk tent in a branch crotch | No tent; silk mats on trunks and branches |
| Main hosts | Wild black cherry, chokecherry, apple, crabapple | Trembling aspen, sugar maple, oak, birch, basswood, tupelo |
| Egg mass ends | Rounded or tapering | Cut off squarely |
Both species are hairy, dark, with blue and yellowish side markings. They grow up to about 2 to 2.5 inches (5 to 6 cm).
Eastern tent caterpillar
The eastern tent caterpillar builds its tent in the crotch where two branches fork. The tent grows as the caterpillar does, and the caterpillars hide inside and come out to feed. Its favourite hosts are in the rose family, including wild black cherry, chokecherry, apple and crabapple. If it runs out of leaves on those, it can wander onto other woody plants.
Feeding damage is usually most noticeable in May, when the large caterpillars are near the end of their growth. Most trees recover, although recently planted or stressed trees can die after repeated defoliation.
Forest tent caterpillar
The forest tent caterpillar builds no tent. Its larvae rest on silk mats on trunks and branches. Its hosts include trembling aspen, sugar maple, oak, birch, basswood and tupelo. It avoids red maple and conifers.
Forest tent outbreaks come and go. They recur roughly every 6 to 16 years and last two to four years, depending on the region. In Manitoba, forest tent caterpillars have periodic outbreaks on aspen.
Telling apart the egg masses in winter
Both species overwinter as egg masses. Each mass is a shiny band of about 150 to 350 eggs, wrapped around a twig. Their European relative, the lackey moth, lays the same kind of band; see caterpillar webs in the UK.
- Eastern tent: the ends of the egg mass are rounded or tapering.
- Forest tent: the ends are cut off squarely.
Egg masses are easy to scrape off twigs in winter, which makes them a simple control.
Life cycle
Both species have one generation a year. The eggs hatch around bud break in early spring, and the larvae feed for about six weeks. The cocoons are white to yellowish. They are found in folded leaves, bark crevices or other sheltered spots.
The adult moths are fairly plain. Eastern tent moths have two pale lines across the forewings. Forest tent moths are buff with two darker lines.
Fall webworm: the late-summer look-alike
Fall webworms are often confused with eastern tent caterpillars, but the timing and location differ. Fall webworms build webs at the ends of branches in late summer and fall. Eastern tent caterpillars build tents in branch crotches in spring.
For the winter webs of browntail, which can also be confused with tents, see browntail moth caterpillars.
Does it matter?
Usually the damage is mostly cosmetic. Healthy trees generally releaf after defoliation by either species. The silk tents can be unsightly on bare early-spring branches, and they may stay in the tree after the caterpillars have left. In orchards, outbreak years can be a serious problem.
Control
- Winter: scrape egg masses off twigs.
- Spring: prune or remove tents on cool or wet days, when the caterpillars are inside. Tents out of reach can be knocked down with a pole with protruding nails or a pressurised hose. Caterpillars can be crushed or drowned.
- Young larvae: Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis) is most effective on small larvae, applied as soon as tents appear in spring.
- Burning: burning tents damages the tree more than the caterpillars do.
- Wild cherry: removing nearby wild cherry trees is not recommended, because cherries are an important native food source for wildlife.
For a general method for telling caterpillars apart, see the caterpillar identification guide.
Horses and eastern tent caterpillars
Eastern tent caterpillar hairs were linked to mare reproductive loss syndrome in Kentucky in 2001. Keep pregnant mares away from infested cherry trees. In outbreak years, keeping horses from grazing near cherry trees, or muzzling them, is recommended. Hairy caterpillars can also irritate the skin, so see stinging and poisonous caterpillars for first aid.
Common misconceptions
- Fall webworms make webs at branch tips in late summer, not crotch tents in spring.
- Healthy trees usually releaf after defoliation by either species.
- Burning tents in trees damages the tree more than the caterpillars.
- Forest tent caterpillars are not “tentless eastern tent caterpillars.” They are a separate species.