The larva, or caterpillar, is the feeding and growing stage of a butterfly or moth. The pupa is the stage that comes after it, when the insect stops eating and its body is rebuilt into an adult. A butterfly’s pupa is called a chrysalis. Moth pupae are often inside a silk cocoon, but not always.
What a larva is
The larva is the caterpillar: a soft-bodied, worm-like feeding machine with a chewing mouth. Most caterpillars have three pairs of true legs on the thorax, the section behind the head, and up to five pairs of fleshy prolegs on the abdomen. The prolegs end in tiny hooks, called crochets, which help the caterpillar grip. Many caterpillars also have a silk-producing spinneret below the mouth.
Most of the caterpillar’s life is spent eating. Caterpillars grow fast, and their body mass can increase about a thousandfold over the larval stage, depending on the species.
Growing through moults
A caterpillar’s skin does not stretch, so it sheds it several times as it grows. This is called moulting, and how many times a caterpillar sheds its skin varies by species. Most butterfly caterpillars moult four times, giving five growth stages, though some species have more. Each stage between moults is called an instar. Shortly before each moult the caterpillar often stops feeding and looks dull, then emerges with a new, larger skin.
The prepupa: the wandering stage
When a caterpillar is fully grown, it stops feeding and empties its gut. It often changes colour and wanders away from its food plant to find a suitable place to pupate. This pre-pupal stage is normal. A caterpillar that is wandering is not lost or sick.
For butterflies, the caterpillar usually spins a small pad of silk on a leaf, stem or other surface, and may also spin a girdle, a silk band that holds it in place. Some species hang in a J shape for a day or so before the final skin comes off.
What a pupa is
The pupa is the non-feeding stage. It does not eat, drink or excrete. It breathes through small openings called spiracles, and it can wriggle its abdomen, which is normal and not a sign that it is dying. The pupa may look still, but it is metabolically busy.
In butterflies, the final larval skin splits and shrinks to reveal the chrysalis. Many chrysalises hang head-down from a silk pad, held by a hook called a cremaster. This is typical of many nymphalid butterflies, such as the Peacock and the Small Tortoiseshell. Others sit upright in a silk girdle, as whites and swallowtails such as the black swallowtail do.
Chrysalis or cocoon
A chrysalis is a bare pupa, with no silk case around it. A cocoon is a silk case that some moth larvae spin around the pupa. Butterflies form chrysalises, and many moths spin cocoons. Some moths form neither, pupating bare in soil instead.
This is a useful way to tell the two stages apart in the field, but it works only if you can see the case clearly. For more on cocoons, see cocoon identification. For what causes a caterpillar to pupate, see how do caterpillars know when to cocoon.
What happens inside the pupa
Inside the pupa, the caterpillar’s tissues are broken down and reorganised. The caterpillar does not simply turn into liquid. Structures called imaginal discs, which were set aside in the caterpillar’s body, develop into the adult’s wings, legs, eyes and other parts. Some tissues, including parts of the nervous system and the breathing tubes, carry through the change.
So the pupa is not dormant. It is metabolically busy, even though it looks motionless.
How long each stage lasts
The larval stage is usually two to four weeks in summer, though some species take longer. The Monarch caterpillar is an example of a fast-growing species, with its stage lasting about nine to 14 days. Overwintering larvae last for months.
The pupal stage is usually around one to two weeks in summer. A Painted Lady chrysalis, for example, typically lasts about a week, while a Monarch’s lasts about 10 to 14 days. The Orange-tip overwinters as a chrysalis for many months. Temperature and day length strongly influence these timings.
Handling pupae safely
A fresh pupa has a soft skin that takes time to harden. Do not handle a new chrysalis for at least 24 to 48 hours after it forms, while its skin hardens. A chrysalis that darkens or turns clear is close to emerging, so leave it alone. Handle other chrysalises as little as you can.
Common misconceptions
- Butterflies spin cocoons. They form chrysalises, which have no silk case.
- The pupa is dormant. It is metabolically active, even though it looks still.
- The caterpillar turns into liquid soup. Some tissues break down, but imaginal discs and other structures persist and develop.
- The pupa feeds or needs water. It does neither.
- A wriggling pupa is dying. Wriggling is normal movement.
For the full picture of the four stages, see the life cycle of a moth.