Butterflies and moths belong to the same order, Lepidoptera, so no single feature separates every moth from every butterfly. There are useful rules of thumb, though. Butterflies usually have club-tipped antennae and hold their wings upright at rest, while most moths have feathery or tapered antennae and rest with their wings flat or tent-like. Each rule has exceptions, so it is best to check several features together.
Are butterflies and moths different groups?
Not in a strict scientific sense. Butterflies are one group within the Lepidoptera, and the rest of that order is made up of moths. Worldwide there are roughly 160,000 described moth species and about 18,000 to 19,000 butterflies. In the UK, the numbers are about 2,500 moth species and 59 regular butterfly species. “Moth” is the broader word, and there are far more moths than butterflies almost everywhere.
Antennae
Antennae are often the quickest clue. Butterfly antennae are thin and taper to a small club at the tip. Most moth antennae are feathery (bipectinate), thread-like or tapered, with no club.
The main exception is the burnet moths, such as the Six-spot Burnet, which have thickened, club-like antennae. Some skippers, which are butterflies, have antennae that look a bit like a moth’s. If you are unsure, look at the tip and at the shape along the whole length.
Wings at rest and wing structure
Most butterflies fold their wings upright over their backs when they settle. Most moths hold their wings flat over the body or in a tent-like shape. There are plenty of exceptions. Skippers rest with their wings partly open, and many geometrid moths, such as the thorns, hold their wings raised.
Most moths also have a frenulum, a bristle or small structure that hooks the hindwing to the forewing so the two work together in flight. Butterflies generally lack one. This is a useful feature to check if you can see the wings clearly, but you will need a close view or a photograph.
Body shape and hairiness
Butterflies tend to have slender, streamlined bodies. Moths often have stouter, hairier bodies, particularly across the thorax. These are tendencies rather than rules: some moths are slim, and some butterflies are fairly hairy. Body shape is the least reliable feature on its own.
Day or night
Butterflies are day-flying. Most moths fly at night, but many UK moths are active by day, including the Six-spot Burnet, Cinnabar, Hummingbird Hawk-moth, Speckled Yellow and Silver Y. A few butterflies, such as the Red Admiral, may fly at night when migrating. So time of day can narrow the options, but it cannot settle the question.
Colour
Many moths are brightly coloured, as a look at colourful British moths shows. The Elephant Hawk-moth, Garden Tiger and Cinnabar are striking examples. Some butterflies are dull and brown underneath. Colour is not a reliable way to tell the two groups apart.
Chrysalis or cocoon
Butterflies form a chrysalis, a bare pupa with a hard outer case, often hung from a silk pad. Many moths spin a silk cocoon around the pupa, or pupate bare in the soil. This difference is useful, but not every moth makes a cocoon, so check it alongside the other features. For more on this, see larva vs pupa and cocoon identification.
Are moths technically butterflies?
Scientifically, butterflies are a group nested within the Lepidoptera, so whether they count as “moths” depends on how you define the word. In everyday English, a moth is not a butterfly, and a butterfly is not a moth. Scientists are still working out exactly how the groups relate to one another, but the practical differences are clear enough for most people.
Does a butterfly turn into a moth?
No. Each species goes through its own metamorphosis, from egg to caterpillar to pupa to adult. A butterfly caterpillar becomes a butterfly, and a moth caterpillar becomes a moth. The two groups use different pupal forms, but the stages are the same.
Why moths get a worse reputation
Moths are often unfairly blamed for damaging clothes, even though only a few UK species, mainly the common clothes moth and the case-bearing clothes moth, eat natural fabrics as larvae (see types of house moths). Most of the UK’s 2,500 or so moth species never come near a wardrobe, and many are beautiful. The reputation comes from the dull indoor pests that people meet most often, not from moths as a group.
Common misconceptions
- Moths are all dull and brown. Many are brightly coloured.
- Moths only fly at night. Many UK moths are active by day.
- Most moths eat clothes. Only a few UK species do, and only as larvae.
- Butterflies and moths are separate, unrelated groups. They are closely related.
- Antennae alone always settle the question. Burnets and skippers can confuse the picture, so check several features.
A quick checklist
- Antennae: club-tipped suggests butterfly; feathery or tapered suggests moth. Check burnets.
- Wings at rest: upright suggests butterfly; flat or tent-like suggests moth. Check skippers and thorns.
- Frenulum: present suggests moth, if you can see it.
- Time of day: day-flying can be either; night-flying suggests moth.
- Pupa: a bare chrysalis suggests butterfly; a silk cocoon suggests moth.
If the features point in different directions, a clear photograph and a local identification guide will usually settle it. For the stages in between, read the life cycle of a moth.