Spongy moths have many natural enemies. In a typical year, they keep populations well below outbreak levels, and disease usually ends the big outbreaks. Birds, mammals, insects and parasitoids take a steady share of caterpillars and pupae. None of them eradicates the moth, and outbreaks still return, on cycles that vary in length.
Fungus: Entomophaga maimaiga
This fungus came from Japan, where spongy moths also occur. It was released near Boston in 1910 and 1911, and its role was not widely recognized until 1989, when it was found in dead caterpillars. It is now a major cause of caterpillar death in many areas.
The fungus needs wet weather in May and June to infect caterpillars. Its resting spores can persist in the soil for years, so it can return when conditions suit it. Caterpillars killed by the fungus hang head-down on tree trunks, stiff and straight. Dead caterpillars left on trunks are sometimes called “empties.” A wet spring often brings a drop in caterpillar numbers from the fungus, even without any treatment.
Virus: LdNPV and Gypchek
A naturally occurring nucleopolyhedrovirus, often written LdNPV, spreads through caterpillar populations, especially at high density. It often ends an outbreak. Infected caterpillars die hanging from bark in an inverted V shape, and their bodies liquefy.
The virus is sometimes called the “wilt disease.” The US Forest Service makes a product from it called Gypchek, which is used mainly in sensitive areas. Gypchek affects only spongy moths.
Mammals
White-footed mice are a key predator of late-stage caterpillars and pupae when spongy moth numbers are low. Heavy acorn years tend to boost mouse numbers, which can in turn help suppress moth numbers. Other mammals, including shrews, chipmunks, squirrels, raccoons and skunks, also prey on them.
Birds
Cuckoos, both yellow-billed and black-billed, eat hairy caterpillars readily. Orioles, blue jays, chickadees and nuthatches also eat them, and in outbreak years, flocks of blackbirds can join in. Birds help at low density, but they rarely stop an outbreak on their own. Disease usually ends the big ones.
Sticky bands can trap birds, bats and beneficial insects, which is one reason many experts advise against them. See how to control gypsy moths? for the details.
Beetles and bugs
Calosoma sycophanta, a European ground beetle introduced around 1906, eats caterpillars and pupae. Native predators include the spined soldier bug and other stink bugs, along with spiders and ants.
Parasitoid wasps and flies
Parasitoids differ from predators. A parasitoid lays its eggs in or on a host, and its young develop inside it and eventually kill it. Several parasitoids attack spongy moths:
- Cotesia melanoscela, a braconid wasp that parasitizes caterpillars. A relative, Cotesia congregata, leaves the white cocoons often seen on tomato hornworms.
- Tachinid flies, including Compsilura concinnata, Parasetigena silvestris and Blepharipa pratensis.
Compsilura concinnata is a reminder that biological control has trade-offs. It also attacks native moths, including giant silk moths such as the Cecropia moth.
Egg parasitoids
Some natural enemies attack the eggs. Ooencyrtus kuvanae and Anastatus disparis are two egg parasitoids that lay their own eggs inside spongy moth eggs.
Biological control history and trade-offs
Since about 1905, dozens of natural enemies have been released in North America to fight spongy moths. Roughly ten or more have become established, though counts vary by source. Biological control is not risk-free. Some introduced agents harm native species, which is why introductions are a trade-off rather than a free fix.
How to help natural enemies
You can support natural enemies rather than work against them:
- Avoid broad-spectrum insecticides. They harm beneficial insects and the small mammals and birds that feed on caterpillars and pupae.
- Use Btk only where it is needed, and spot-treat. It also kills the caterpillars of butterflies and other moths.
- Keep sticky bands off trees. They can trap birds, bats and beneficial insects.
- Protect healthy trees. Trees that are in good condition handle defoliation better.
Are these agents safe for people and pets?
The fungus Entomophaga maimaiga and the LdNPV virus do not infect people or pets. Caterpillar hairs can still irritate skin, though, so wear gloves when you handle caterpillars or egg masses. Are gypsy moth caterpillars poisonous? covers the rash and first aid.
Common misconceptions
- “Birds can control outbreaks.” Birds help at low numbers, but disease usually ends outbreaks.
- “A stiff, head-down caterpillar and an inverted-V caterpillar mean the same thing.” Fungus-killed caterpillars hang straight and stiff, head-down. Virus-killed caterpillars hang in an inverted V and liquefy.
- “Natural enemies will eliminate spongy moths.” They do not. Outbreaks still recur.
- “Biocontrol is risk-free.” Some agents harm native species.