Usually not from one year of feeding. A healthy hardwood can survive a heavy defoliation and grow a second set of leaves. The bigger threat is repeated heavy defoliation over two or three years, especially when drought comes at the same time. Oaks are especially at risk, and eastern white pine and hemlock can die after a single complete defoliation.
What defoliation does to a tree
Caterpillars eat leaves, and a tree responds by growing new ones. A tree that loses more than about half its leaves usually grows a second set by midsummer. Caterpillars do most of their feeding late in the season, so this regrowth often happens in July. Regrowing leaves use stored carbohydrates, and the second set is often smaller and sparser. That draws down the tree’s energy reserves and weakens it.
One year is usually survivable
Most healthy hardwoods survive a single defoliation, even a heavy one. A bare tree in June is usually not dead, because most hardwoods leaf out again. Wait until the next spring before deciding that a defoliated hardwood is dead. Healthy trees also usually releaf after forest tent caterpillars strip them; see eastern tent caterpillar vs forest tent caterpillar.
Why repeated years matter
Two or three consecutive years of heavy defoliation sharply raise the chance a tree will die, especially for oaks. Drought in the same years greatly increases the risk.
Weakened trees are often finished off by other pests and diseases. In oaks, the two-lined chestnut borer and Armillaria root rot are common examples. In that sense, spongy moth is often not the direct cause of death, but it leaves the tree vulnerable.
In the 2015 to 2018 southern New England outbreak, which overlapped with drought, many oaks died.
Oaks are the most at risk
Oaks are the main host, and stands with more than about half their trees as oak are the most at risk. Mortality varies a lot with the site, the tree’s vigor and the weather, so the same outbreak can kill some trees and leave their neighbors unharmed. For the full list of hosts, see what trees do gypsy moths eat?
Conifers are not safer
Eastern white pine and hemlock can die after one complete defoliation, because conifers refoliate poorly. Evergreens generally suffer more from defoliation, not less. Older caterpillars can eat conifers, including hemlock, pines and spruce, from about the fourth stage of growth.
Signs a tree is declining
Watch for:
- dieback starting at the top of the tree
- a thinning crown
- sprouts growing from the trunk
If you see these signs, have a certified arborist assess the tree. A single sign is not proof of death, so keep watching over the following growing season.
How to help a stressed tree
These steps can help a tree that has been defoliated:
- Water deeply during dry spells, especially after defoliation.
- Mulch around the root zone.
- Avoid damaging the roots, for example through construction or soil compaction.
Fertilizing is not generally recommended after defoliation, because its benefit has not been proven. If you are unsure, ask an arborist before applying anything. To reduce caterpillar numbers before they defoliate a tree, see how to control gypsy moths?
Dying trees can be a hazard
Dying oaks can drop large limbs. If a damaged tree is near your home, a path or a power line, have a certified arborist assess it promptly. Confirm that the arborist is certified before you hire them.
Recent outbreaks in Ontario and the US
Ontario reported record defoliation in 2020 and 2021, although reported figures vary by source. In the US, defoliation peaked at about 12.9 million acres in 1981, by approximate estimates. Outbreaks rise and fall. Weather, natural enemies and the number of egg masses all influence how bad a year gets. For how natural enemies affect outbreaks, see natural predators of spongy moth caterpillars.