How to identify a peppered moth
The peppered moth (Biston betularia) is a geometer, a member of the family that includes carpets, pugs and thorns. Its wingspan is about 45 to 62 mm. It flies from May to August and is often found at lights, because it is mainly a night flier. Are moths nocturnal? explains how night and day flying differ.
Check these features:
- Antennae: males have feathery antennae, and females have thread-like ones. You may need a clear photo to see this.
- Wing pattern: the typical form is pale with fine black speckling, which gives the moth its name.
- Resting posture: like many geometers, it usually rests with its wings held flat.
Pale moths with black marks can look alike, so check the antennae and the overall pattern before naming one. If yours does not match, see what kind of moth is white with black spots?. The UK moth identification guide lists the checks to make, in order.
The three colour forms
The peppered moth has three main colour forms. They are variants of one species, not separate species.
- typica is the pale, speckled form that gave the moth its common name.
- insularia is intermediate in colour between typica and carbonaria.
- carbonaria is near-black.
The carbonaria form is the one that became common during the industrial period.
The caterpillar and its foodplants
The caterpillar looks like a twig, as many geometer looper caterpillars do. It matches the colour of its host plant and holds its body stiffly out from the stem. Its foodplants include birch, willow, oak and hawthorn, along with many other trees and shrubs. The moth overwinters as a pupa in the soil.
Why its colour changed
During the Industrial Revolution, soot darkened the bark of many trees, and the lichens that grow on bark were lost in polluted air. Against this darker background, pale moths stood out, so birds found and ate them more often. Dark moths were better camouflaged, so more of them survived to breed. This is the main explanation for the change, and it rests on evidence from several studies.
The first carbonaria was recorded in Manchester in 1848. By about 1895, about 98% of the moths sampled there were carbonaria.
In 2016, researchers traced the dark form to a transposable element, a piece of DNA that can move, inserted into a gene called cortex. They dated that insertion to around 1819, about three decades before the first record in Manchester.
After the Clean Air Acts of 1956 and 1968 reduced smoke and soot, carbonaria became rare again. How common it is now varies from place to place, but the dark form has not died out.
The Kettlewell experiments
In the 1950s, Bernard Kettlewell released marked moths in a polluted woodland near Birmingham and in an unpolluted woodland in Dorset. He then recaptured them. In each place, the form that was better camouflaged was recaptured more often, which he took as evidence that birds hunt by sight.
His methods have been criticised. He released many moths during the day, when they do not normally fly. A moth released in daylight may settle on the first surface it reaches, rather than where it would naturally rest. Some critics have also claimed he faked his data, but the evidence does not support that.
Later research on bird predation
Michael Majerus ran a much larger experiment between 2001 and 2007, releasing about 4,800 moths. His results, published in 2012, supported the view that birds preferentially take moths that stand out against their background.
Where peppered moths rest by day
Peppered moths are hard to find resting in the wild, so their hiding places are still debated. Field observations suggest they rarely rest on exposed trunks and are more often found at trunk and branch joints or under branches. This matters because some early experiments placed moths on trunks, and critics argued that this did not reflect how the moths really rest.
Common misconceptions
- Individual moths did not change colour. Colour is inherited, so a moth did not change colour during its life. What changed was the proportion of dark moths in the population.
- Carbonaria has not gone extinct. It became much less common after the Clean Air Acts, but it still occurs.
Recording peppered moths
Peppered moths come to lights in summer, so you may see one in a garden or on a porch. A clear photo that shows the wings and antennae, with the date and location, makes a useful record. For the wider picture of changing moth numbers, see why moths are declining in the UK.