Short answer
The most common thing mistaken for a caterpillar is a sawfly larva. Sawflies are wasp-like insects, not moths or butterflies. The simplest test is to count the prolegs: true caterpillars have up to five pairs, while sawfly larvae have six or more. Sawfly larvae also have a single eye spot on each side of the head. Other common lookalikes include beetle grubs, ladybird and lily beetle larvae, hoverfly larvae and garden invertebrates such as millipedes and slugs.
The prolegs test
Every caterpillar has three pairs of true legs on the thorax, the three body segments behind the head. Its abdomen can carry fleshy false legs called prolegs. Most moth and butterfly caterpillars have up to five pairs, on abdominal segments 3 to 6 and 10. The prolegs end in tiny hooks called crochets. Loopers have only two pairs. Sawfly larvae have six or more pairs, and their prolegs lack crochets.
Counting legs on a moving larva is unreliable. Photograph it from the side, with the body stretched out, and count the prolegs from the picture.
Common UK lookalikes
| Lookalike | What it is | How to tell |
|---|---|---|
| Sawfly larvae | Larvae of wasp-like insects | Six or more pairs of prolegs; a single eye spot on each side of the head |
| Gooseberry sawfly | A green sawfly larva with black spots | Found on gooseberry and currant |
| Solomon’s seal sawfly | A grey sawfly larva | Feeds on Solomon’s seal |
| Scorpionfly larvae | Caterpillar-like, living in leaf litter | Prolegs on eight abdominal segments |
| Ladybird larvae | Dark grey with orange spots and long legs | No prolegs; alligator-like shape |
| Lily beetle larvae | Orange-red grubs covered in their own black droppings | Feed on lilies and fritillaries |
| Hoverfly larvae | Legless, slug-like maggots that eat aphids | No legs |
| Leatherjackets (crane fly larvae) | Grey-brown, legless and tough-skinned | Found in lawns; no legs |
| Millipedes | Hard bodies with two pairs of legs on each segment | Many body segments |
| Centipedes | Fast, with one pair of legs on each segment | Harmless to people in the UK; handle gently |
Sawflies on gooseberry and roses
Green larvae on gooseberry are almost always sawflies, and some sawfly larvae on roses look similar. When disturbed, many sawfly larvae rear up in an S-shape, often in unison. Because they are not caterpillars, caterpillar-only controls such as Bt sprays don’t work on them. Pick them off by hand if you need to.
Myths to avoid
- A looping larva with only two pairs of prolegs is still a true caterpillar. These are the inchworms, which are geometer moth larvae. See looper caterpillars.
- A slug-shaped larva can still be a true caterpillar. The slug caterpillars of the Americas are moth larvae; see what does a slug caterpillar turn into?
- A motionless larva is not necessarily dead. It may be resting or about to moult.
- Colour is not a reliable test. Use the prolegs and the food plant first.
For the main chart of UK caterpillars, see the UK caterpillar identification chart. For green larvae, see green caterpillars in the UK.
Safety
Most lookalikes are harmless. Don’t handle centipedes roughly, and wash your hands after handling any invertebrate you find in the garden. For hairy caterpillars that do cause irritation, see are fuzzy caterpillars poisonous?.